Chief Justice speaks out after Arizona voters oust 3 judges
Arizona Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer said the state’s judicial retention system is “broken” after voters removed three judges in the November 2026 election. She said the losses were devastating and warned that the state risks losing qualified judges without changes.
The three judges removed were Court of Appeals Judge Anni Hill Foster, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Julie Mata and Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Michael Rassas, according to election results reported by KJZZ.
Mata was removed with 51.3% opposed and 48.7% in favor, a drop from her 75.8% support in 2022.
Foster, who was appointed by Gov. Doug Ducey in 2022, was removed in her first retention election with 50.2% of voters opposing her retention and 49.8% supporting it. Rassas was removed with 50.6% opposed and 49.4% in favor, compared to 69.5% support in his previous retention election.
Both Republican and Democratic groups advised against retaining all three judges, according to KJZZ. Partisan voter guides and organized campaigns to oust judges were more prevalent in 2026 than in prior years, with initial results showing those efforts were partially successful.
Foster faced opposition from the Maricopa County Republican Committee and Legislative District 4 Republicans, as well as progressive groups including Arizona Judge Watch, State + Local Election Alliance and Gavel Watch. LD4 Republicans cited two cases: Foster authored an opinion dismissing a lawsuit from Strong Communities Foundation of Arizona over Yavapai County election procedures, and she sat on an appellate panel that declined to release certain Maricopa County election records. Progressive groups opposed Foster citing her tenure as Ducey’s general counsel, where she was involved in cases concerning abortion rights, immigration, the shipping container border wall, federal COVID relief funds and vaccinations.
Mata consistently ruled in favor of the Republican-controlled Legislature this cycle, including allowing the Goldwater Institute’s measure banning diversity, equity and inclusion to appear on the ballot. She ordered the removal of the word “vouchers” from the Protect Education Act and found the measure failed to alert voters of “government control or supervision of private schools and homeschools.” Those rulings landed her on the do-not-retain list for progressive groups, while Maricopa County Republicans did not provide a specific reason for opposing her. Mata also appeared on signs urging voters to “REJECT BAD JUDGES” from the PAC Arizonans for Judicial Accountability, primarily funded by donor Dan Brophy, a board member for the conservative Arizona Liberty Network.
Rassas faced opposition from Democrat-leaning groups over low scores from the Commission on Judicial Performance Review, a group of citizens and attorneys that grades judges via survey and public comment. He was endorsed by the conservative Arizona Free Enterprise Club, and LD4 Republicans listed three family law cases where his rulings were overturned by a higher court.
Timmer said the retention election results were akin to “shooting fish in a barrel,” noting some judges were unaware of campaigns against them. She said it has become increasingly difficult to attract and keep qualified judges, adding, “Changes have to be made if we want to save the sanctity of our judicial system.”
“You can get people. There’s always people. But can you get the best?” Timmer said, according to KJZZ. She said some sitting judges have expressed regret over shaky job security and negative internet sentiment.
Timmer plans to form a committee to analyze the 2026 elections, develop policy changes to the merit selection and retention system, and counsel judges on campaigning before 2028. Initial ideas include extending term limits and raising the percentage of no-votes necessary to remove a judge.
The merit selection and retention system is in the state constitution, so any proposals must go through the Legislature and then to voters as a referendum. In 2024, voters rejected a Republican proposal to limit retention elections to judges who failed to meet performance standards, with 77.7% opposing it.
The system traces to 1974, when voters swapped direct judicial elections for merit selection. Since 1992, it has included the Commission on Judicial Performance Review. Timmer noted drafters could not have predicted social media and artificial intelligence as new factors. She is up for retention herself in 2028, asking, “What do I tell the judges? What do I tell myself?”
Comments are closed.